A Zen Story on ‘looking’

The Disciple (Rakhi Varma, 2020)

There was, once upon an old, old time, a Zen Master who was both revered and feared throughout the land in Japan. It was said that if there was ever a master artist, it was he. Rumour had it that he could teach a stone to paint. At the same time, a talented young painter in a far away town heard these tales about the master. He was filled with the urge to become his apprentice. He had already built himself a small reputation and thought that the great master might impart to his art some final finesse, teach him some tricks, which would benefit him greatly. The idea grew on him. One day, having made up his mind, he set off to the remote mountain village where the master dwelt.

In due course, he found himself in the master’s presence. The master looked nothing like the flamboyant character of his stories. Just an ordinary looking fat old man he was. Anyhow, the young man conveyed to the master his wish to polish his already vast pool of skills under the great man’s guidance. The master, who usually chased such aspirants away, took one look at him and accepted him as his disciple. One doesn’t know what he saw.

When the student is ready, the master appears.
– Buddhist Proverb

“Go and paint me a sleeping sow,” ordered the master, starting off the class immediately. Delighted at such an easy assignment, the young painter set off promptly. Loitering in the quiet village, he came across some sows, female swine, sleeping in the mud. They suited his requirement perfectly and he settled himself down to paint. It was nothing. Before the day was out, he was done.

He walked back to the master’s hut on the hill, happy and whistling, eager to show off his work. “Master…”, he said and bent low, offering his painting to the wise man, waiting to hear special praise. The very next moment, he saw his painting being hurled right outside the window, down the steep, green curve of the hill. Aghast, he looked at his mentor. Too stricken to speak. The master repeated the order, “Paint me a sleeping sow.”

Bewildered, the man staggered out of the compound, satchel in hand. “Did I paint too many sows? Did the master just ask for one? Was it the angle, perhaps? Or, may be, the light? No answers came. But he was quite confident that he could do an infinitely better job, whatever may have been the fault. Off he went the next morning and soon found some sows sleeping by a pond. He painted again. On second thoughts, he painted two more. And a fourth one. All from different angles, different gradients of light and colour. Whatever he could think of as an improvement upon his previous attempt. It took him three days but he thought nothing of it. He was never one to shy away from hard work.

When the paintings were ready, he returned and offered them to the master. And waited. The master took a second each to look at all of them, and, without a word, threw them out of the window once again. The man rushed forward, horrified, as if to save them. Little bits of white twirling down to the endless bottom. “You have lost nothing. They are no use,” said the master in his serene voice. “Paint me a sleeping sow. Go.”

Day after day, he went and sat with sows. He looked and he looked, and he painted nothing but sleeping sows. He gave up food and drink. He forgot to bathe. He went mad. It went on for days. For months. Through rain and thunder. But, the master would throw his paintings, tear them up, crumple them. Not one painting met his expectations. And the young man’s confidence dropped to his bootlaces. He had nothing left but his battered self, as vulnerable as an open field.

We are all broken… that’s how the light gets in.”
– Ernst Hemingway

Sohbat (Rakhi Varma, 2020)

So came the glorious moment when he could not take it any more. Riddled with anxiety and frustration, he flew into the master’s room in the middle of the night and cried out: “What is wrong with my paintings? I have done all I can. Now, I need to know! Tell me, master!”

Ah…the necessary anger… The master smiled a smile of deep satisfaction. “At last you found it in you to ask the right question. What took you so long…?”  He asked, not for the answer, but for the impact. The painter frowned, taken aback. The master said, “I asked you to paint me a ‘sleeping’ sow. Not a ‘dead’ sow. The two are not the same. All your sows were great, but seemed dead.”

At that moment the young painter experienced satori.

“It’s not what you look at that matters, it’s what you see.”
Henry David Thoreau

You only see what you are. To see the other, a sleeping sow, a bird, a tree, a beloved, you have to become it. It needs emptying. When the young painter was emptied of his ego, he became a true artist.

Upstream by Mary Oliver

“Attention is the beginning of devotion.”

Upstream, Selected Essays by Mary Oliver lays down in a thousand compelling ways that one most essential truth of life: To live is to give life, and everything that flows in it, your fullest and deepest attention. Oliver’s lilting prose traverses the several layers of ‘looking deeply’ with the playfulness of a child, the graceful sharpness of a master painter, and the desire to understand of an utterly sincere scholar. All with the vulnerability of being truly human.

She pours into the rich cauldron of her essays everything she encounters, or that encounters her. There’s the strand of the river she follows upstream, which is sometimes frozen icy blue. And a thread of Noah, the oak tree she named and whom she kisses on the first day of every spring. There’s a dizzy field of sunflowers and all the other blossoms she honors and surrenders to. And the scent of Walt Whitman, the most luminous of all American poets, who is to her that other lost half of her poet’s road map. And, then, there is a pinch of questions she asks of the world changing too fast, too soon, and too irreparably. She asks urgently, soulfully,

“Doesn’t anybody in the world anymore want to get up in the middle of the night and sing?”

Seemingly light, Upstream is a bubbling treatise on what does it mean to have this experience, this beyond-the-dictionary-magnificent and incomprehensible ‘thing’ that we all are in–a question that has caused thinkers, visionaries and scientists to write tomes upon, since the beginning of it all. Where exact answers seem to leave too much unanswered, Oliver crawls into the mystery of Existence, literally sometimes, ‘looking’ simply, equally and honestly:

Step In (Zahir, 2020)

“Deep in the woods, I tried walking on all fours. I did it for an hour or so, through thickets, across a field, down to a cranberry bog. I don’t think anyone saw me! At the end, I was exhausted and sore, but I had seen the world from the level of the grasses, the first bursting growth of trees, declivities, lumps, slopes, rivulets, gashes, open spaces. I was some slow old fox, wandering, breathing, hitching along, lying down finally, at the edge of the bog, under the swirling rickrack of trees.

You must never stop being whimsical.”


So, she goes altering the reasons for which we exist in this world, making it the most important job on earth to simply look at everything. Foxes, turtles, Canada geese, black-backed gulls and herring gulls, terns, frogs, musk rats, American blue herons, snowy egrets, owls, spider crabs, sea robins, sharks, duckweed, insects, grass… Just look. Isn’t that all one has to do, open one’s eyes, in order to ‘find’ the world we so ardently pray for? All realms are here within this one.

But if this book is about a fuller opening up to life, it is equally a meeting with the darker layers of our soul-material, the impossible ironies of living, the contrasts: The struggle of hunger, death and sorrow, because that’s the other half of being alive. That’s what makes it whole. Here’s a passage that brings into brilliant light one of those sudden moments of “spiritual dilemma” that lull our chaotic brains into simple acceptance of whatever is.

Oliver writes,

“Once, on a October day, as I was crossing a field, a red-tailed hawk rattled up from the ground. In the grass lay a pheasant, its breast already opened, only a little of the red, felt-like meat stripped away. It simply flew into my mind–that the pheasant, thus discovered, was to be my dinner! I swear, I felt the prick of sweet luck! Only secondly did I interrupt myself, and glance at the hawk, and walk on. Good for me! But I know how sparkling was the push of my own appetite. I am no fool, no sentimentalist. I know that appetite is one of the gods, with a rough and savage face, but a god all the same.

Teilhard de Chardin says somewhere that man’s most agonizing spiritual dilemma is his necessity for food, with its unavoidable attachment to suffering. Who would disagree.”

Looking (Mansi Teotia, 2020)

Her honest meditation on “appetite–this other creature consuming appetite” flows into the wish to be “beyond all that”, and into owning an “inherited responsibility” towards all life forms, where you don’t take what you won’t use, and, as often as possible, give something back into the pool, for “…we are lambs and we are leaves, and we are stars, and the shining, mysterious pond of the water itself.”

And the more one forgets oneself, the more one merges with the essence. The spectacular Virginia Woolf said somewhere, “To look life in the face, always, to look life in the face and to know it for what it is. At last to know it, to love it for what it is…”

Oliver’s trip is the same as she goes hunting and looking, not just around her, but in the vision of those giant redwoods of literature, whose enduring wisdom we return to again and again: Ralph Waldo Emerson, Edgar Allan Poe, Wordsworth, and, of course, Walt Whitman. Each of them is a separate essay, and in the essay, a fathoming of their lives, their works, the dark and bright of their souls.

She tells us how Emerson was “adamant that we should look, we must look, for that is the liquor of life”. Could that be repeated, echoed, underlined and applied enough? She divines that his “trick” of writing was that he filled his essays with ordinary things and married them with concepts that were overarching. And isn’t that life as we experience it? And isn’t our confusion the same as Poe’s, which he writes and rewrites into each of his stories: “…the anguish of knowing nothing for sure about the construct of the Universe, or about the moral order within it…?” She says,

“When in “The Masque of the Red Death” the stranger who is really nothing but an empty cloak enters and slays the Prince, it is Poe and it is ourselves with him who rush forward and batter hopelessly against that incomprehensibility, with our frails fists, with “the wild courage of despair””.

Poe’s wild courage of despair, so utterly human, and Whitman’s ecstatic and freeing Leaves of Grass. Oliver drinks from both, opposite ponds, seeking their essence equally, going past the formalities of form and content, both. Of Whitman’s most luxurious and vibrant poem she writes:

“So hot is the fire of that poem, so bright its transformative power, that we truly need, and Whitman knew it…
…There is a madness born of too much light, and Whitman was not after madness nor even recklessness, but the tranquility of affinity and function. He was after joyfulness, a belief in existence in which man’s inner light is neither rare nor elite, but godly and common, and acknowledged.”

Oliver never once ceases to employ what she has learned or has found resonance with, but takes it to heart, to her soul, making Upstream much more than can be expressed. It is poetic and densely scholarly, and astute too. It is not just as though she offers us her kaleidoscope to view this world of myriad forms, but that she is the kaleidoscope herself. The structure of her looking is the structure of her poetry and prose. And what she trains her eyes on is not only itself, but the magic of her ‘looking’ deeply.  She is a wanderer of the world on a constant, reverent high.

“Over and over in the butterfly we see the idea of transcendence. In the forest we see not the inert but the aspiring. In the water that departs forever and forever returns, we experience eternity.”

To that we kneel and kiss the ground.

When The Malti Spoke

Recently, I came across a picture of a quiet, thickly wooded alpine forest somewhere. The trees on the outer edge of the picture seemed to be creating an ‘entrance’ over the path below. As if inviting one to come, cross over the threshold into another world. Their world. And on that picture were written the words –

Just Sitting (Raghu Soman, Summer 2014)

‘Not all classrooms have four walls…’ 

Walls imply straitjacketing, boxing. A restricting of vision and imagination. Like putting blinkers on a gorgeous horse to keep it on the path. It means a classroom where avoiding the thrust of life means the same thing as ‘discipline’. Where being different is being an outcast.

…Whereas being out there, in the classroom beneath the azure sky, amidst towering trees and the cacophony of birds, in the society of wilderness, means waking up that imaginative, intuitive creature within… It implies living fully, learning only what’s necessary, and intuiting, rather than thinking. Getting lost means being in the presence of one’s own flow. And learning happens not by means of discipline, but simply by existing in sync with all other life forms.

Our new story from The Little Space is an experience from this very classroom without four walls. Yes, even a bit of forest in one’s yard is as alive and as powerful as the dense jungles of the Terai. Even one tree, one plant is enough to awaken that consciousness within, which is the precursor to living deeply. Symbiotically.

“Three months ago, we planted two tender Madhumalti saplings near the guard room, at the entrance to our society,” writes Shambhavi, our co-passenger and caregiver at The Little Space. “One of the Madhumaltis had an electric cable near it. As is its nature to climb, it soon gave out its first climbing shoots. It seemed that it was ready to begin its ascent. The other sapling, too, sprouted a few new leaves. But there were no climbing shoots to be seen. We waited. Nothing happened. So, we waited more…”

Waiting is of two kinds. The first waiting is part of a restless effort, where one anticipates getting somewhere, achieving something. The other kind of waiting is simply being present. It is knowing that life is a force that is constantly flowing. Taking care of itself. Like the untouched alpine forest.

“And then one day,” she says, “We saw that the first bel of Malti had started coiling around the black electric cable, starting to grow by leaps and bounds. It grew nearly 3 to 4 inches in a day…! Much excited, we ‘thought’ we should give it more support, since the cable was quite short. So, we put a metal wire in front of both the plants for them to climb around. But, three days later, we saw that both Maltis had turned away from the wire…!”

Listen…says the forest. Don’t think. Sit here with me, watching with your heart.

Maali Kaka, Shambhavi’s guide and ally intuited, “They are asking for something smooth to climb up on…Iron wires won’t do…” He was interpreting the signals, just as he had learned to over the years. “But where does one get smooth-surfaced things to help the Madhumaltis, and what?” thought Shambhavi, concerned.

 To care about someone other than yourself, enough to open your heart to its life, is the Gomukh of bliss.

“Find the sweetness in your own heart, then you may find the sweetness in every heart.”
– Rumi

“The wires get heated up, I guess… Let’s try coir ropes then,” she decided quite like a child, trying to come up with ideas she never had the need, rather, the sparkling chance to think of before. “Then, we got a coir rope. But our society guard, whose help we had enlisted to put it up, literally created a web of rope around the creepers to induce them to make their ascent! In addition to that, he nipped off the apical meristem of the Malti that was now more than 5 feet tall. The creeper stopped growing…!”

The apical meristem of a plant is that tender green tip that produces something called auxin and that helps the plant grow. To push up its head and look out at the world it is born in. It’s almost as if your curiosity pushes you to grow. Somehow, that sounds true…

And to have it blocked…cut off…

“As the first Malti stopped growing and the second one still refused to give off any shoots…” Shambhavi shared, trying to make sense of the drama, the struggle. After a week, Maali Kaka again made the same humble submission: “It needs something smooth… Let me think of a way out…”

How often do you know the answer in your heart but don’t take the leap…?

Maali Kaka decided to listen to it. “He removed the web of coir, allowing the creeper to breathe and free up,” she, said, as if exhaling along with the plant. “Then, he took a smooth black pipe and fixed it near the second creeper. And within two days it let off a climbing shoot!”

The Madhumaltis of The Little Space (Shambhavi Singh, Winter 2020)

What wonder! What relief! The plant gave a roaring sign of approval of their understanding. Yes, now you are with me and now our hearts are one–it might have breathed silently, showing its gratitude by shooting up fast, as if time didn’t matter. It doesn’t.

Thinking cannot reveal what life can.

And so filled to the brim, Shambhavi wrote, “Hopefully it will start coiling around the pipe and begin its ascent. And what shall we do once it reaches the end of the short pipe? Well, we’ll just let the Madhumalti tell us!”

There’s movement in those words, the promise of a new relationship, of joy and deep change. Isn’t there? It is so liberating to know that you don’t have to try too hard. That life guides you to the next step and the next… Isn’t it remarkable to feel this connection with it? All one has to do is to sit down next to it and listen…

To a tree. To a dog. A raincloud. A little boy. A waxing candle. The moon. The seasons. Everything. Everywhere. 

Shambhavi picked out her marvelous learning from this class and wrote, “I have observed that Maali Kaka never claims to know it all. All he ever does is to observe the plant closely. As if hearing it’s voice. Sometimes, when he feels a plant isn’t looking well, he tends to it a little more than usual, giving it some water, a bit of manure…just that extra dose of love.”

“Knowledge speaks but wisdom listens,” said Jimi Hendrix. He also said, “Excuse me while I kiss the sky…”

Let’s slow down to kneel and kiss the ground, and the sky… Slowing down doesn’t mean giving up. It means tuning in to the frequency of the other. And your own. For the real you who needs to rise and breathe, and coil up on the smooth arm of this Universe. Like the Madhumaltis of The Little Space, to whom we are grateful for this sublime new learning.